We Found the 8 Best Concealers for Sensitive Skin, Starting at Just $5 (2025)

TL;DR

Our Top Picks

Coverage Level: Medium | Finish: Natural | Shades: 20 | Size: 0.16 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Associate editor Abby Dupes was thoroughly impressed with this concealer right off the bat. Despite the name, which might imply more sheer coverage, we loved how pigmented it was, effectively covering up dark circles, acne spots, and more. It also earned rave reviews for the perfectly skin-like finish that was neither too dewy, shiny, or too matte. It was easy to apply and blend, and never caked or creased. The only thing Abby lamented was that it wasn’t slightly more long-lasting, which is why she felt it was best for everyday wear, rather than special occasions where you want something that will stay put for hours and hours on end.

Abby Dupes, associate editor: “I’m a tough critic when it comes to concealers—I want something that brightens my under-eyes and covers acne spots without looking cakey.This one does exactly that!”

Coverage Level: Medium | Finish: Radiant | Shades: 21 | Size: 0.17 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

If you’ve previously had a hard time finding the right concealer color for your skin (#relatable) consider checking out this product. With over 20 different hues, including a variety for darker skin and a wide range of undertones, there’s something for every complexion. Our tester, editor Eden Stuart, was really impressed by how well it blended into her complexion. Other things she liked: How light it felt while wearing it, a subtle, natural finish, and that it didn’t cause any breakouts. That being said, it’s not very long-wearing; she noticed it had faded and looked a bit cakey at the end of the day; she also felt it could’ve been better at hiding dark circles.

Eden Stuart, editor: “This offers a really nice color match for me! Plus, it's smoothing and brightening. It maintains its hydration throughout the day, thanks to ingredients like saffron flower and rosehip extracts, which I think are key for how well it wears”

Coverage Level: Buildable | Finish: Dewy Shades: 24 | Size: 0.25 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Our tester, associate social media director Star Donaldson, greatly appreciated the dewy (not greasy) finish of this concealer, as well as how hydrating it felt on the skin. It’s also pretty pigmented; she only needed a tiny bit to score the coverage she craved. On that note, it worked equally well to hide both dark circles and rosacea-induced redness, as well as generally evening out the complexion. However, despite being billed as creaseless, she definitely noticed some creasing after wearing it all day.

Star Donaldson, associate social media director: “I think it’s a good fit for those with sensitive skin as it lacks fragrance and didn’t cause breakouts or irritation and left my skin feeling hydrated, not dry."

Coverage Level:Medium |Finish:Radiant |Shades:9 |Size:0.1 oz |Cruelty-Free:Yes

With a nice array of options for deeper skin tones (which, unfortunately, isn’t always the case with concealers) this concealer easily earned its superlative. The texture is creamy and hydrating, and the pigment—aside from also having a good range of varying undertones—did an excellent job of hiding hyperpigmentation. While our tester, Byrdie editor Olivia Hancock, generally liked how it felt on the skin, she did find that it sometimes got a bit chalky.

Coverage: Buildable | Finish: Luminous | Shades: 17 | Size: 0.2 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Our favorite thing about this winner? How beautifully it covered up dark circles and illuminated the entire area around the eyes, making it look nearly air-brushed. It works great for other imperfections, too, and while it is on the lighter side, it’s very easy to layer for extra coverage. Bonus points for the fact that it’s fragrance-free and contains white water lily extract to soothe and hydrate skin.

Read Full Review: Reviewed: BareMinerals Original Liquid Mineral Concealer Lasts Me All Day

Lynn, tester: "At almost 59 years young, my skin tends to be on the drier side, but this lightweight concealer offered hydration and plenty of coverage."

Coverage: Sheer | Finish: Radiant | Shades: 9 | Size: 0.2 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

You may recognize this winner from social media; it was an instant TikTok fave when it launched a few years ago. It’s sheer for sure; our tester, Alexandra, deemed it better for blurring and brightening rather than delivering full-on coverage. Still, she loved how nicely the gel-like texture blends into the skin. It also touts cucumber extract and squalane to keep irritation at bay.

Alexandra, tester: "I love the finish and color match, it feels very hydrating and flexible on the skin."

Coverage Level:Full |Finish:Matte |Shades:17; Light to Deep |Size:0.17 oz |Cruelty-Free:Yes

A clean, super-high coverage concealer that you can get at the drugstore? Yes, please. This worked beautifully for covering up a range of complexion imperfections—dark circles, redness, scars, and more. Top tip: It is definitely on the thicker side, so we found that applying it with a makeup sponge yields the most seamless result.

Coverage Level: Full | Finish: Natural | Shades: 24 | Size: 0.40 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

This concealer lives up to its name—it offers very full coverage. In fact, it was so much coverage that we could pair it with just a bit of tinted moisturizer and forgo foundation entirely. It was equally great at delivering said coverage to dark circles, acne, and prominent pores. There is a bit of a learning curve to figuring out exactly how much product to dispense from the squeeze tube. If you use too much, we found it tends to crease.

Holly Rhue, editorial director: "This is my go-to concealer because of how great the coverage is. It’s just the best! Thick enough to cover any problem areas, but it still looks natural.”

FAQ

• What type of concealer looks best on sensitive skin?

  If your skin is prone to redness, concealers with pigments added to balance or counteract redness (typically green tints) will be very helpful.

• What does sensitive skin look like?

  Sensitive skin can show up in many different ways and as mentioned, can be oily to dry. But one very common characteristic is reactive. That can manifest as anything from bumps and blushing to a rash-like appearance.

• Is fair skin more sensitive?

  Fair skin is more prone to sunburn, but not necessarily more prone to irritation.

Article Sources

Byrdie takes every opportunity to use high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial guidelines to learn more about how we keep our content accurate, reliable and trustworthy.